Best Rototillers For Large Gardens – 2019 Top Picks Reviewed

Finding a rototiller for a large garden space can seem intimidating, but it is absolutely necessary. Rototillers can save you so much time and effort and can be a true game-changer in a large gardening area. Read on to learn more about these amazing tools and what they can do for you. 

Comparison of the Best Rototillers For Large Gardens

Product

Rating

Price

Schiller Grounds Mantis 4-Cycle​

Schiller Grounds Care Mantis 7940 4-Cycle Tiller Cultivator Powered by Honda – Lightweight, Powerful and Compact - No Fuel Mix, Sure-Grip Handles – Built to Be Durable and Dependable

Best Overall

TroyBilt Horse 20" 306 cc​

Runner-up

Dirty Hand Tools Tiller

Dirty Hand Tools | 101571 | Front Tine Tiller with Kohler Engine | 15 Inch Tilling Width and 10 Inch Tilling Depth | Counter Rotating Tines and Adjustable Depth Regulator

Best for the Money

TroyBilt Colt 24 in. 208 cc​

Southland Outdoor Power Equipment ​

Southland Outdoor Power Equipment SFTT142 Front Tine Tiller

How Do I Choose a Tiller For My Garden?

Because there are so many different kinds available, we have provided a list of qualities to keep an eye out for and help narrow the list down:

Toughness

If you are investing in one of these for your larger garden, odds are much higher you are going to encounter hard soil, roots, or even rocks. You want to make sure you find yourself a model that is strong enough to deal with anything it may come across.

Versatility

Rototillers for large gardens tend to be more on the expensive side of the gardening tool spectrum. If you are going to spend that amount of money, you might as well spend it on a tool that can accomplish more for you beyond tilling. Get one that is also excellent for digging trenches or heaping up dirt to make raised beds.

Durability

Tilling, unfortunately, is not a one and done type of task. Oftentimes, you will need to run one of these over your garden multiple times in a row, and at the very least, you will need to till your garden at least once a year when winter ends. Find yourself a unit that can stand up to the task and go the distance for you.

Quick Take | Best Rototillers For Large Gardens

Before you move to the our full review of the best rototillers for large gardens, here is a quick take of the top 3 models:

  1. Schiller Grounds Care Mantis 4-Cycle
  2. TroyBilt Horse 20 in. 306 cc
  3. Dirty Hand Tools Front Tine Tiller

Review of the Best Rototillers For Large Gardens

Now that you know more about the purpose of these models, and some specific qualities to look out for when choosing a hand tiller, let’s go check out an actual list of products:

Schiller Grounds Care Mantis 7940 4-Cycle Tiller Cultivator Powered by Honda – Lightweight, Powerful and Compact - No Fuel Mix, Sure-Grip Handles – Built to Be Durable and Dependable

PROS

  • Comes with included engine oil
  • Handles are ergonomically designed
  • Only twenty four pounds, so incredibly easy to transport
  • Tills effectively through all different kinds of dirt, including compacted dirt

CONS

  • Not great at tilling tree roots

The Schiller Grounds Care Mantis 4 Cycle Cultivator is an amazing rototiller and our best overall choice for an option designed to be used in large gardens.

This machine has a number of great features, including ease of operation (users report it will always start up on the second or third pull, so say goodbye to yanking the cord over and over). It runs super quiet, so you will not have to stress out about disturbing your family members or your neighbors.

If rocks, plant matter, and hard soil become jammed into the tines, the process of removing the tines and cleaning them is clear and straightforward. Plus, you will not have to waste precious gardening time assembling this tool, as the whole thing takes less than twenty minutes to set up.

Bottom Line

The Schiller Grounds Care Mantis 4 Cycle is the premiere option for large gardens, and our best overall choice. Be wary of using this tool anywhere you anticipating encountering tree roots, though.

PROS

  • Robust construction
  • Engine runs strong and smooth
  • Unit arrives already well greased
  • Durable, will last for years and years
  • Tough enough to stand up to a lot of abuse

CONS

  • Troy Bilt does not provide good customer service
  • Forward and reverse shifting is difficult to do while it's running

The Troy Bilt Hose 20 in. 306 cc Rear Tine Gas Tiller is a top notch rototiller and our runner-up option for best overall rototiller for large gardens. This is a boss, thanks to its strong, sturdy construction that will enable it to accomplish basically whatever you need it to do. It can easily break up even the hardest soil without getting bogged down, and its engine will consistently run smoothly even if it is chewing through tough dirt.  

It is versatile enough to be used for a wide range of different tasks – users report it is great at tilling large gardens, flower beds, and smaller gardens, but also that it can be used to make raised beds, to dig drainage trenches, and even as a snow plow! If you are looking for a great garden tool that can do it all for you, you will find it in the Troy Bilt Horse 20 in 306 cc .

Bottom Line

This model is a great option that can do a lot more than just till your large garden. Just keep in mind that it is difficult to move the machine from forward to reverse while it is running.    

Dirty Hand Tools | 101571 | Front Tine Tiller with Kohler Engine | 15 Inch Tilling Width and 10 Inch Tilling Depth | Counter Rotating Tines and Adjustable Depth Regulator

PROS

  • Set up is quick and easy
  • Typically starts on the very first pull
  • Wheels can also serve as a tilling depth adjustment system.
  • Smaller than its competitors, so able to fit into tighter spaces.
  • Our choice of best for the money.

CONS

  • Wheels are a little close together
  • Gearbox tends to heat up quickly

If you want to find yourself a rototiller that can easily manage your large garden, with effectiveness and efficiency, but will not totally destroy your budget? Such a tool sounds impossible…until you find the Dirty Hand Tools Front Tine Tiller! This machine works so great, you will not believe its price.

It can till down to four inches deep, and it has a lot of power, so it can chomp through some harder soils. It has side and rear safety shields which effectively prevent flying debris and accidental injury. And, for an additional safety feature, ts wheels are six inches in diameter, which definitely help to keep the tool more stable.

Bottom Line

The Dirty Hand Tools Front Tine Tiller is a phenomenal option that you will not be able to believe costs as little as it does. Just know that it can be a little difficult to maneuver sometimes, since its wheels are quite close together.

PROS

  • Durable and heavy
  •  Has a great deal of power
  • Can run in reverse as well
  • Comes with a quality carburetor

CONS

  • Handlebars are narrow and make leverage difficult
  • It is a complicated process to untangle the plants and weeds from the tines

The Troy Bilt Colt 24 in. 208 cc is a great product choice that will always be effective at tilling large garden spaces. This machine is remarkably reliable, always ready to start on the second pull at the very latest. It can chomp through anything you throw at it, including buried rocks and bricks (we are serious!).

The adjustable overhead valves are in a convenient location, and you can also adjust the handlebar height in order to fit your specific needs. Plus, it does not take a ton of effort on the part of the user. Can you find a better machine than that? We didn’t think so.     

Bottom Line

The Troy Bilt Colt 24 in. 208 cc model is an awesome option with a number of great convenience features, including adjustable handlebars, handy overhead valves, and an overall smooth ride that will not take a lot of work on your part. The only inconvenience is the process of cleaning off the tines.

Southland Outdoor Power Equipment SFTT142 Front Tine Tiller

PROS

  • Has a lot of power
  • Well made and robust
  • Comes with supplied oil
  • Easy to set up and to use
  • Tines are self sharpening

CONS

  • Takes a lot of effort to use
  • Southland does not provide good customer service

This is a fantastic model for large gardens, for a number of different reasons. This tiller is surprisingly quiet, so say goodbye to frustrating your neighbors with your gardening noises. It can easily chomp through sod and big rocks, and it is excellent for tilling fresh ground that has never been tilled before.

It has variable tilling widths at eleven inches, sixteen inches, and twenty one inches, so it is quite versatile. Plus, its gear drive system is extremely durable and one you will be able to rely on for years to come. There is not much to dislike with this model!

Bottom Line

The Southland Outdoor Power Equipment Front Tine Tiller is a rockstar that will be able to handle whatever you throw at it, even if it is a large outdoor space that has never been used for gardening or tilled before. It does take a good amount of effort to use and to control, but we guarantee you will be satisfied with the results.

Best Uses for a Rototiller in a Large Garden

So now that you know more about rototillers, what are the best ways you can use them? Here are the best ones we could come up with:

Leveling the Ground

If you have never used a tiller before in your gardening area, odds are pretty good that the ground you intend to garden on has a lot of bumps and dips. Rototillers are excellent for leveling out the ground and making it a smooth gardening surface.

Getting Rid of Weeds and Rocks

You do not want to plant a garden in soil that is super rocky, or is already being choked to death with weeds. Rototillers are some of the most effective tools on the market when it comes to removing these pests from soils and making it more plantable.

Aeration

Even if you have already planted in the soil before, and even if it does not have a high level of rocks or weeds, it is still worthwhile to use a rototiller just to shake the soil up. The more aerated the soil is, the healthier your plants will be.

Conclusion

Rototillers are the true MVP's of the gardening world, especially if you have a large gardening space. Make sure you take into account what you need from this type of machine, in terms of durability and versatility. We know that if you choose a model from our reviewed list, you will not regret it. 

Leave a Comment